Concept of reason in jurisprudence
-
Concept of reason in jurisprudence
The notion called reason or cause (causa petendi in the terminology of the Roman tradition), or even claim, responds to the need, felt by the study of process, for a link between substantive law and process through the statements of the party that takes the initiative of the judgment, aspiring to be right.
Therefore, the reason is essentially intended to recall and represent in the process the legal situation at issue according to the unilateral appreciation of the party that takes the initiative of the judgment.
The reason relied upon by the latter is nothing more than a one-sided and controversial presentation of the existing situation; and whether it is based on facts or not cannot be determined while the case is pending. It follows that, in the field of procedural law, it can and must be spoken of as a reason relied upon, even if, upon examination by the judge, it appears not to correspond to the real legal situation, that is, to be wholly or partially unfounded.