Reply To: How to measure temperature
EncycliosOrganizerMay 4, 2023 at 12:42 PM
Temperature problems in metrology
One of the main attributes of an ideal measuring system is to only respond to the designed signal and ignore all other signals. Temperature variations adversely affect the operation of the measuring system and hence the concept of an ideal measurement has never been completely achieved. It is extremely difficult to maintain a constant-temperature environmental condition for a general-purpose measuring system. The only option is to accept the effects due to temperature variations and hence, methods to compensate temperature variations need to be devised.
Changes in dimensions and physical properties, both elastic and electrical, are dependent on temperature variations, which result in deviations known as zero shift and scale error.
Whenever a change occurs in the output at the no-input condition, it is referred to as zero shift. A zero shift is chiefly caused by temperature variations. It is a consequence of expansion and contraction due to changes in temperature, which results in linear dimensional changes. Zero indication is normally made on the output scale to correspond to the no-input condition, for most of the applications.
A very common example is setting the spring scales to zero at the no-input condition. Consider an empty pan of the weighing scale. If there is any temperature variation after the scale has been adjusted to zero, then the no-load reading will be altered. This change, which is due to the differential dimensional change between spring and scale, is termed a zero shift.
Temperature, especially when resilient load-carrying members are involved, affects scale calibration. Temperature variations alter the coil and wire diameters of the spring, and so does the modulus of elasticity of the spring material. The spring constant would change because of the temperature variations. This results in changed load-deflection calibration. This effect is referred to as a scale error. Various methods can be employed in order to limit temperature errors:
- Minimize temperature errors by proper and careful selection of materials and range of operating temperatures. The main reason for the occurrence of temperature errors is thermal expansion. When simple motion transmitting elements are considered, only thermal expansion causes temperature errors. Temperature errors are also caused when thermal expansion combines with modulus change when calibrated resilient transducer elements are considered. In the case of electric resistance transducers, thermal expansion combines with resistivity change to cause temperature errors. In each of these cases, temperature errors can be minimized by appropriately choosing materials having low-temperature coefficients. While selecting such materials, one needs to keep in mind that other requisite characteristics such as higher strength, low cost, and resistance to corrosion will not always be associated with minimum temperature coefficients. Hence, a compromise needs to be made.
- Provide compensation by balancing the elements comprising inversely reacting elements or effects. This depends on the type of measurement system employed. In the case of mechanical systems, a composite construction can be used to provide adequate compensation. A typical example is the composite construction of a balance wheel in a watch or clock. With the rise in temperature, the modulus of the spring material reduces and the moment of inertia of the wheel increases. The reason for this may be attributed to thermal expansion, which results in the slowing down of the watch. A bimetal element having appropriate features can be incorporated into the rim of the wheel to counter these effects such that the moment of inertia decreases with temperature so that it is enough to compensate for both expansions of the wheel spokes and change in modulus of the spring. When electrical systems are employed, compensation may be provided in the circuitry itself. Thermistors and resistance-type strain gauges are examples of this type.
- Control temperature such that the temperature problem is eliminated.